Deep Analysis of SD-WAN Technology Schools
2023-03-28
Since 2014, the term SD-WAN has been officially heard in the North American market, and to this day, the global installed capacity has reached nearly 100000 nodes. And the Chinese market is also catching up! Based on technological and supplier differences, several major factions have emerged: pure software led SD-WAN, SDN-WAN (network resource led), Cloud Express (cloud gateway), device led, and wide area network optimization. The following text is provided by Lingrui Lanxin, a company that focuses on SD-WAN technology and serves nearly 530 large and medium-sized enterprise users. We will provide you with a detailed analysis of the current SD-WAN technology trends in the market.
Pure Soft SD-WAN
Through user understanding, SD-WAN should meet the following main business needs of enterprise users:
-
In order to improve the final experience of application software, edge sites or branch offices of enterprises can flexibly call public network lines and private WANs. The two can be load balanced or mutually backed up, and can switch between primary and backup based on link usage, latency, jitter, etc., rather than link based on on on/off switching.
-
Support black box and white box deployment and the ability to deploy or software form user terminals on cloud platforms, namely CPE, vCPE
-
Having a secure hybrid wide area network system with DPI functionality, allowing for dynamic scheduling of resources within the system (including private and public wide area networks) based on specific application software policies, rather than specifying a specific resource, in order to achieve higher network resource availability and application layer performance, and with corresponding optimization techniques to enable certain poorly performing lines to support business operations.
-
Visualize business and management, prioritize setting, regulate core business and real-time applications, and ensure security and compliance
-
Can achieve centralized management and control, while also being able to individually regulate policies for a certain edge node without affecting global deployment
-
A highly available and resilient hybrid wide area network that can achieve the best user experience (including application performance experience)
-
Interoperability of 3-7 layer networks
-
Instant status and performance reporting of dashboard style sites, applications, and private virtual networks
-
North facing APIs can be opened, allowing users to redevelop and call all the functions of the front-end; Ability to push specific log events to network event managers (SNMP, netflow), and preferably have a Security Incident&Event Manager
-
0 touch deployment, plug and play to ensure business agility
-
End-to-end network and security control
-
FIPS 140-2(Federal Information Processing Standard Publication 140-2)证书,自动更新证书的生命周期管理与报告
In fact, the term SD-WAN was coined by the pure soft faction, so classifying them as SD-WAN orthodox also respects the fact. This faction focuses more on the software defined level, emphasizing the use of software functions to control and coordinate circuit and hardware resources to achieve overall efficiency, meet the needs of enterprise users for business and application layer deployment in wide area networks, strive for refined management, obtain better user experience, and enable quick deployment and simple operation and maintenance. In this form, software modules account for 80-90% of the architecture and are loosely coupled and integrated with circuits and hardware devices without specificity.
It can be understood that if the enterprise user does not have a specific dedicated line, the pure soft SD-WAN can directly use ordinary Internet lines (enterprise broadband, and support PPPoE), 3G/4G and even the future 5G for networking. The software module enables various optimization functions to provide users with a better experience than traditional networking IPsec VPN.
For users who already have fixed lines, such as the mainline MPLS/SDH and Internet backup network mode, software led SD-WAN can directly utilize these lines to form a large bandwidth resource pool, and make good use of each line through fine control without being picky.
For network hardware, due to the powerful all in one capabilities of software, it can replace devices such as routers, load balancing, and wide area network acceleration to achieve cost reduction goals, and support users to use third-party whiteboard hardware.
In addition, due to the emphasis on soft capabilities, this technology genre mostly integrates soft security modules and has strong firewall capabilities, which can to some extent replace firewall devices. It is worth mentioning that this genre uses API interfaces commonly used in the software industry, bringing convenient secondary development feasibility to users.
Lingrui Lanxin Ruizhitong SD-WAN
Overall, software led SD-WAN has strong flexibility, serving enterprise users directly and integrating with operators. Users can gain refined control capabilities, business agility, flexibility, high reliability, flexible scalability, certain optimization capabilities, and lower costs (compared to dedicated lines).
From the perspective of usage scenarios, it can solve the problemHybrid-WAN,SD-Branch,SD-Security,Edge WAN-controlling,WAN-access Bonding,WAN-optimization,Application visibility/AccelerationThe needs that enterprise users are more concerned about. However, the streaming party requires high software integration capabilities, so the strength of software capabilities can also lead to differences in service levels.
Resource based SDN-WAN and Cloud Express
Firstly, let's briefly review SDN, also known as Software Defined Network, which is a large-scale network design, construction, and operation architecture that utilizes the software of a central controller to program and control the forwarding strategies of routers and switches. From the definition, it can be seen that the central controller, programmable forwarding strategy, is the focus of SDN. Looking back at the origin of SDN, if Nicira company is used as a symbol, the origin time can be considered to be in 2007. It is not difficult to find that during that era, even when Nicira was acquired by VMware in 2012, the main operating model in the market was still "enterprise application software mainly deployed in data centers, radiating branch offices and sales outlets". As a new technology for large-scale network management and operation, SDN has made great contributions to the construction, management, coordination, and operation of data center networks! Especially with OpenFlow as the mainstream protocol and interface standard, SDN has established its position in the data center era.
However, with the global economic reform and the emergence of e-commerce, mobile Internet and cloud technology, the business models of companies have begun to change, requiring more flexibility and agility, and closer to the end user. Therefore, enterprises have increasingly high requirements for wide area network transmission! And the focus of SDN is not on wide area networks, so SD-WAN emerged. The similarity between the two is that both use software as a means to control and manage the network, and both have central controllers in the form of software. The difference is that SD-WAN places more emphasis on wide area networks. That is to say, it is more suitable for enterprises to transmit various business and application data through wide area networks. Many network workers familiar with SDN like to refer to SD-WAN as an extension of SDN technology to wide area networks. In fact, this understanding is not accurate. The author would prefer to describe it this way: SDN can be seen as the enlightenment of SD-WAN, but there is still a significant difference in technology between the two.
Resource-based genre
The "resource-based genre" specifically refers to suppliers who possess network resources, characterized by having their own underlying backbone network, while the SD part is built on top of the backbone network. A good resource-based manufacturer will fully utilize SDN technology to finely manage its own network POP points and backbone network, and integrate software modules such as TCP/UDP optimization, intelligent routing, data compression and re deletion that are helpful for application layer data transmission at each network POP point to improve service quality. For the last mile access of a wide area network (WAN), it is usually a comprehensive solution that utilizes the user's existing internet to connect to POP nodes through IPsec VPN, forming an SDN-WAN. Therefore, this type of solution can also be called an SDN-WAN solution. Strictly speaking, this solution is not considered an end-to-end SD-WAN solution, as suppliers are usually not responsible for the quality of the last mile of links. A responsible manufacturer will provide a terminal device loaded with the optimization module mentioned above to ensure a user experience, but the cost will also be slightly higher. Generally speaking, only one set of devices that can support IPsec VPN may be provided, or even the client's own devices may be used.
The characteristic of this genre is having its own backbone network, and configuring a terminal device is not a technical challenge. Therefore, some traditional line operators have also entered this field, claiming to have SD-WAN solutions. But if it cannot fully meet business needs, especially if there are few solutions that include software control and optimization capabilities, the industry generally believes that they are just ordinary wide area network access services, not SD-WAN The quality of the backbone network itself is also one of the main factors restricting the performance of SDN-WAN solutions. Although SDN technology itself lacks the ability to optimize low-quality networks, good suppliers can integrate corresponding wide area network optimization modules at POP points or terminal devices to achieve results. However, not every supplier is willing to spend the cost to do so, so users need to carefully identify.
Another issue is that SDN is mainly designed to better address the north-south line services of large IDCs (including cloud IDCs), without the need for complex scenarios in enterprise wide area networks. Therefore, implementing WAN connection services in this type of solution is not a problem, but it cannot fully meet the fine requirements of enterprises for deploying application layers on the WAN, nor does it face the optimization and control of service processes in the business layer, which cannot fully meet the demand of enterprise service experience first.
In summary, this genre has available existing network backbones that can be quickly expanded into SDN-WAN solutions after integrating software capabilities and terminal devices. For enterprise users, the comparability of using SDN-WAN locked in by one operator is relatively high, which cannot meet the flexibility of deployment, thus losing future agility. Considering the deployment needs of some enterprises for ultra remote services, such as across countries, pure soft SD-WAN loaded with ordinary Internet still lacks good remote performance. SDN-WAN with high-quality backbone network and the ability to integrate and optimize is still one of the main choices.
Cloud Express
Cloud Express. Due to the reuse of SDN within cloud architecture, Cloud Express essentially belongs to this genre, with a greater emphasis on providing fast access to the cloud for enterprises. However, the quality of such services often depends on the cloud service provider's understanding of the wide area network.
Device type SD-WAN
"Device type" is relatively easy to understand, mainly due to the development of solutions by existing network hardware equipment manufacturers who hope to enter the SD-WAN field, but cannot abandon their original equipment products. Upgrade the software of traditional devices to support a unified management interface. This type of solution may have a simple central controller or none at all, and it tests the software capabilities of hardware manufacturers. In most cases, it can only manage hardware from its own brand. Controlling customer terminals is the essence of such solutions. If old customers do not plan to change the equipment brand, they can try it out.
Wide Area Network Optimized SD-WAN
This technology genre is the closest to pure soft SD-WAN among all SD-WAN technology genres. Supplier Uni President is a solution provider for traditional wide area network optimization. For these manufacturers, the wide area network optimization software capabilities (TCP bilateral transparent proxy as the main feature, and advanced suppliers also have data compression/re deletion functions) are already well done, and the SD-WAN architecture does indeed integrate wide area network optimization capabilities as an important function, allowing this genre to have a competitive advantage. Regardless of whether or not they have a central controller, they can become SD-WAN suppliers.
However, as mentioned earlier, SD-WAN is a brand new overall enterprise networking solution, and optimization is only one of its capabilities. It emphasizes more on the sorting and control of user business and application layers, as well as corresponding advanced security functions, which are not possessed or weakly exist in the wide area network optimization technology faction.
Summarize
Looking back at the ONUG SD-WAN research report, which cites the summaries of enterprise user CIOs/CTOs, and real cases from overseas and Chinese markets over the past five years, we recognize that SD-WAN is the first network solution that adapts to the superstructure of enterprise IT architecture. It is not difficult to understand, because the top priority for enterprises in various fields is to develop their core businesses, and ICT technology only serves as an important tool to serve the top priority. The application software directly serves the business, therefore, the more fully the Software Defined part of SD-WAN is done, the more it can meet the needs of the enterprise, and the more quickly it can be recognized by enterprise users. Software Defined covers at least three levels: workflow organization and transmission optimization for enterprise business layer and application software layer (including data layer), with business agility; Process optimization for the service-oriented concept; Finally, safety and reliability are essential conditions. From this perspective, it can be seen that SD-WAN, as a convenient ICT tool at the enterprise level, can support enterprise users to achieve efficient and refined control and business agility, thereby better allocating limited resources to do core business well and improving the end user experience.
Related News